Nathaniel married Thankful Morse on 17 Feb 1760 in Shrewsbury, Worcester, Massachusetts Bay, British Colonial America. Thankful was born on 22 Sep 1742 in Shrewsbury, Worcester, Massachusetts Bay Colony, British Colonial America; died on 13 Mar 1790 in Alstead, Cheshire, New Hampshire, United States; was buried in 1790 in Alstead Center, Alstead, Cheshire, New Hampshire, United States. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Nathaniel married Rhoda Goddard on 11 Feb 1793 in Petersham, Worcester, Massachusetts, United States. Rhoda was born on 25 Feb 1740 in Shrewsbury, Worcester, Massachusetts Bay Colony, British Colonial America; died on 7 Dec 1820 in Pittsfield, Rutland, Vermont, United States; was buried in Ludlow, Windsor, Vermont, United States of America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]