Jonathan married Mary Cheney on 24 Nov 1738 in Medfield, Norfolk, Massachusetts, United States. Mary was born on 7 May 1713 in Medfield, Suffolk, Massachusetts Bay Colony, British Colonial America; died on 12 Jul 1755 in Holden Center, Holden, Worcester, Massachusetts Bay Colony, British Colonial America; was buried in 1755 in Old Burying Ground, Holden, Worcester, Massachusetts, United States. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Jonathan married Rachel Mansfield on 18 May 1756 in Holden, Worcester, Massachusetts, United States. Rachel was born in 1715 in Worcester, Massachusetts, United States; died on 8 Nov 1781 in Holden, Worcester, Massachusetts, United States; was buried in Nov 1781 in Massachusetts, Worcester County, Holden Town, Old Burying Ground. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]